
Chris Gayle queries reviews
The ICC's decision review system (DRS) was the one sticking point that saw Ricky Ponting and Chris Gayle take different sides of the fence.
The DRS, in use for the first time in Australia after its full implementation by the ICC, has proven to be the major talking point of the first Test - apart from the Windies' underwhelming performance in the one-sided fixture.
Players from both camps have generally praised the DRS, which allows each side two unsuccessful reviews per innings.
That trend stopped abruptly today when Gayle renewed his criticism of the DRS.
"As I've said before, I'm not a big fan of it," said the Windies skipper after his team slumped to a comprehensive innings-and-65-run defeat late on day three.
"I need your (the media's) help, hopefully you can change it for me.
"Maybe you guys can help me? I can't say too much."
However, when pressed, Gayle did advance on the reasons behind his frustrations.
"The technology is always there, but sometimes mistakes are still made even with the technology - that's why I'm not a big fan of it," he said.
"We might as well just go with the two umpires in the middle and leave it as is, whether they get it wrong or right."
Ponting, an ardent supporter of the DRS, was in complete disagreement with Gayle's analysis about the potential for oversights.
"It's always going to be good for the game, whether or not every one is right is irrelevant," Ponting said.
"We end up getting more correct decisions made in the game. I think we used ours pretty well. They probably referred a couple that were wrong."
"I think the umpires did a great job themselves and the referral system worked well as well."
Ponting backed the system, even given the case in his side's first innings when third umpire Mark Benson did not overturn a decision despite replays being quite supportive of Mitchell Johnson's claim that he did not produce an edge.
"It was probably inconclusive on the replays if it was out or not out, but you stick with the decision because that's the way it would have been without the system anyway," he said.
"I think right through the course of this game it's worked really well and I've been a big supporter of it since we used it in South Africa the first time around, which was a long time ago.
"Out of that series it was proven that there were probably an extra 20-odd correct decisions made in the series, so that can only be a good thing for the game."
There has been much discussion over how best to take advantage of the DRS.
With the power to challenge the umpire's raised finger resting with the batsman out in the middle as opposed to the team, some have questioned whether challenges made by Gayle and Shivnarine Chanderpaul in the first innings were emotional more than anything else.
Gayle was unapologetic for asking for a review in both innings, despite Benson confirming on both occasions that he was indeed trapped lbw by Ben Hilfenhaus.
He said: "It's there to use, so why not give it a chance? It's one of those things where it doesn't matter what I think... the umpire's decision still stands.
"We have to deal with it. It's there, so we just have to use it. Hopefully it can go in our favour (next Test) - that would be nice."
Although Australia posted an emphatic victory today, the visitors will take heart from having unearthed a star of the future with opener Adrian Barath notching a record-breaking century on debut.
Barath, 19, overtook George Headley as the youngest West Indian to score a Test ton, and was also the youngest man to plunder a century against Australia since Indian prodigy Sachin Tendulkar did it almost 18 years ago.
But he received little support, with the Windies crashing to 187 all out in their second innings, handing Australia an early win after Ponting enforced the follow-on after lunch.
Ben Hilfenhaus snared figures of three for 20 from his seven-over opening spell, making light work of Gayle (one) and Chanderpaul (two) before all-rounder Shane Watson finally brought an end to Barath's magic.
Hilfenhaus' efforts saw him earn man-of-the-match honours, but there was no doubting the day belonged to the debutant, who crafted the only century for the match in some style.
Powered by Disqus
