Saturday 4th February 2012

ICC surprised by DRS impact

ICC surprised by DRS impact

ICC general manager, Dave Richardson, has admitted even he has been taken aback by the impact of the Decision Review System on Test cricket.

The ongoing series between Pakistan and England in Dubai has seen 35 lbw decisions, nine of them on Friday alone, to break previous records, and much of it is down to the DRS system helping bowlers out.

Richardson admitted he never expected to see such a change to the game following the introduction of DRS.

"It's doing what we planned for it to do and it's working both from an operative perspective, and everybody's elses, including the umpires' perspective," he said.

"I would say that in subcontinental conditions, it's surprised me that it's in a way changing the game more than I thought it might, certainly for spinners. The spinners believe they can get more wickets, they are appealing for more, and the umpires are giving them."

But Richardson said he believes this is a positive development as it removed the notion that batsmen should receive the benefit of the doubt - a convention not written in the laws of the game.

"I think it's not a bad thing," he said. "We were keen to make sure there was a better balance between bat and ball.

"I think there was a feeling it had gone too much the other way and batsmen were getting too much of an easy ride in Test cricket. Wickets were too flat and the balance had shifted too far in favour of the batsmen, so I don't think it's a bad thing that there's something for the bowlers."

Although Richardson had not foreseen the impact on the subcontinent, he finds it easy to explain now.

"When you talk about the pitches here, the ball doesn't bounce as much," he said. "In England, Australia, and everywhere else, it's amazing how many balls, even from the spinners, are creeping over the top of the bails, whereas here they are below the bails.

"I think it has had more of an influence in these conditions than anywhere in the world."

The system has provoked strong reactions, both positive and negative, since its introduction as some believe it takes away from the authority of on-field umpires.

However, Richardson believes umpires have found it beneficial.

"I think the general view is supportive," he said. "I think they acknowledge it can be to their benefit. Any mistake can be rectified while still giving them margin for error.

"They don't need to change the way they umpire and the system will support them more often than not."

The system will undergo a thorough review in May, and Richardson is hoping a study by Cambridge University will produce statistics to show it has been a success.

Such numbers, if found, might then help persuade the Board of Control for Cricket in India to back a system they have so far opposed.

"I think they'll take some persuading," Richardson added. "Hopefully the results will confirm what we think - that this is accurate enough for our purposes - and hopefully as a result of those India will reconsider."


Powered by Disqus
  • Join us on Facebook Join us on Facebook


standard
 

  • ESPN is a trademark of ESPN, Inc and STAR is a trademark of Star Television Productions Limited. Trademarks used under license by ESPN STAR Sports.
  • Presented by ESPN, Star Sports, Star Cricket